This is gonna probably be a bad time, considering the influx of questions, but in Gold, Silver and Crystal, Blaine’s gym burns down, and it’s just him in that small cave (this won’t apply to HG/SS, where he had like a full gym, with puzzles and trainers.) Why do you think the Pokemon League let him stay as an official leader if it was just him in a cave?

Some of my speculation on the anime episodes regarding Blaine might be relevant: http://pokemaniacal.tumblr.com/post/28403196447/anime-time-episodes-58-and-59

In short, I think that because Blaine holds the rank of Gym Leader, and has given the League no reason to strip him of that rank, he has the inalienable right to run a Pokémon Gym in any area which currently lacks one.  He may even have access to a certain degree of League funding to assist in its upkeep (hence the more complete Seafoam Gym in Heart Gold and Soul Silver).

What do you think it would be like to live inside a pokeball. And if gamefreak were to call you right now tell you that you get to design the next set of legendary pokemon what would you design and would you say yes.

Hmm.

Good question.

I am convinced that Pokémon remain self-aware while in Pokéballs, since they seem to be able to leave them of their own accord, and they can hear attack commands issued to them before they leave the balls.  On the other hand, they lose their physical bodies and exist as some form of energy.  I imagine it’s a lot like dreaming; your mind feels like it’s filled with fog, and you’re aware something about your situation is very odd, but you’re not really bothered all that much by it.  You might be vaguely aware of the real world, and it’s relatively easy for an outside stimulus to snap you out of it.  A more expensive Pokéball may help make this state more pleasant, or more appropriate to a particular kind of Pokémon (being in a Lure Ball is like dreaming of swimming, for instance).

Now, if Game Freak wanted me to do their work for them… well, how much would they pay me? 😉  Seriously, though – that would be a lot of fun, but I don’t think legendary Pokémon are something that should necessarily be designed in isolation.  I believe they should be created with close reference to the story the game is supposed to be telling, and I don’t have any such story to work from at the moment.  I do have a series of entries planned for the near future that may give you a better answer to this, though…

Glaceon

Official art of Glaceon, by Ken Sugimori; all glory to Nintendo.So, if you read my entry on Leafeon all the way to the end, you may have gleaned that I don’t particularly think much of Glaceon either.  It’s nothing personal.  I actually have a certain affection for Glaceon; she’s pretty cute, as Ice-types go, and she’s not exactly a terrible Pokémon either.  On sober reflection, though, I think she’s rather bland, and, much like Leafeon, struggles to develop an aesthetic or competitive niche within her large family.

With an elegant, lithe exterior concealing incredible powers over ice and snow, Glaceon is certainly an adorable yet dangerous Pokémon… but there’s not really a lot to her.  She has a sort of diamond motif that I guess creates a pleasing allusion to snow crystals, and she’s… blue.  Which is good, because ice is sometimes blue.  As an Ice Pokémon, she is capable of causing her body temperature to plummet, draining heat from the air around her to create chilling gales.  This also freezes her fur into needle-like spines, which she can fire at her ene-

Wait.  Go go gadget Pokédex.

“It lowers its body heat to freeze its fur.  The hairs then become like needles it can fire.”

Game Freak, are you seriously telling me you got so lazy that you stole Jolteon’s flavour text?

 Glaceon trecking through a snowstorm, by Viperidaemon (http://viperidaemon.deviantart.com/).

Yes, that is exactly what they are telling me.  What’s more, because it worked so well for Jolteon, they chose to represent this power in game with a silly little move that no-one will ever use (I don’t care how badly you need a priority attack) because Glaceon’s physical attack stat is appalling – Ice Shard.  Unlike Jolteon, Glaceon doesn’t really look like she has any business using an attack like this, probably because it’s something that was pasted on at the last minute and not an actual part of the design.  I’m sorry, but if this doesn’t say “we ran out of ideas” then I don’t know what does.  Glaceon’s elegant and beautiful like Vaporeon, sure, but Vaporeon is a creative hybrid of terrestrial and aquatic features, whereas Glaceon is just a nice shade of cyan.  She has magical freezing abilities, but so do most other Ice Pokémon.  I don’t think I would be upset with this design if I thought there were an evolution on the way; it feels incomplete, as though it’s waiting for elaboration, and detail… but no; Glaceon is the evolution.  I find myself without any reason to care about her.

As with Leafeon, Glaceon’s method of evolution makes it obvious what kind of environment she’s meant for (if her icy powers weren’t already enough of a clue) – set off by the Ice Rocks found near Snowpoint City in Sinnoh and beneath Twist Mountain in Unova, Glaceon is a cold-adapted Eevee, at home in alpine and boreal forest terrain.  It’s strange that she doesn’t seem to have any of the features normally associated with cold-adapted species, like large size (to reduce your surface area to volume ratio) and thick fur (for insulation), but I suppose many of the normal rules for living in cold climates go out the window anyway for Glaceon and for several other Ice Pokémon, who are actually colder than their surrounding environments.  Glaceon fights by chilling the air around her, so for her a high surface area, and hence small size, makes sense to maximise her ability to drain heat from the atmosphere.  Glaceon and Leafeon are the first Eeveelutions to really embrace the idea that Eevee’s unusual properties are a result of her adaptability, which is great, because it’s a fun idea that gives Eevee and her weird split evolution a great deal of significance and some interesting implications.  However, they also neglect to do much of anything with the idea.  Forest Eevee is a Grass-type, alpine Eevee is an Ice-type; they take on the characteristics of the environment that they live in… but this leads to Leafeon competing with tall trees for light to photosynthesise, and Glaceon using cold attacks to defend herself from other cold-adapted species.  This is a slight problem that hides beneath a lot of Pokémon, but we tend to ignore it because there’s a certain intuitive rightness about it.  When you set up a species as ‘the adapter,’ though, it draws attention to the fact that it doesn’t actually make a lot of ecological sense for Pokémon to adapt in this way and develop these powers… more on that next time, though.

 Glaceon playing with a snowflake, by Lovelyfantasy (http://lovelyfantasy.deviantart.com/).

As far as battles go, Glaceon has one big, important selling point: she commands the most powerful Ice attack in the game (barring legendary Pokémon), a devastating Blizzard which, backed up with Hail to boost its accuracy, will level just about anything that doesn’t resist it.  Realistically, Ice Beam is a lot more reliable, and will still hammer the opposition pretty severely.  This, sadly, is where the good news ends.  Ice is a great offensive type, hitting four other elements for super-effective damage, including Dragon.  However, it is also hands-down the worst defensive type in the game, sporting only a single resistance (to itself).  This would not be such a problem if Glaceon were set up as a sweeper, but she isn’t – she’s actually quite slow.  Her greatest assets, after her monstrous special attack, are her defence and special defence, which, in combination with her poor HP, are good but not amazing (to be fair, she can boost her physical defence with Barrier and retaliate against special attacks with Mirror Coat, but that takes time and moveslots).  Glaceon will face a lot of hits from faster Pokémon as she attempts to freeze-dry her way to glory, and although she’s pretty bulky for an attacker, the lack of resistances makes it very difficult for her to handle repeated assaults.  It also reduces her suitability for using all the neat little support moves that her family has access to, like Wish, Baton Pass, Heal Bell and Yawn.  The other major problem for Glaceon is that, like all her brothers and sisters before her, her offensive movepool is quite small.  After Ice Beam, she’s got Shadow Ball and Signal Beam, which are helpful but don’t have a lot of power and are from fairly weak elements – and the truly damning thing is that, if she wants to manage neutral damage against most Steel-types, she has to resort to the decidedly lacklustre Water Pulse (available from a 4th-generation TM).  Basically, she has the wrong stats and movepool for a sweeper, the wrong type for a tank, and no other viable choices.

As far as I can tell, Black and White didn’t do much for Glaceon… if anything.  The new move tutors in Black 2 and White 2 seem to have added Hyper Voice to her movepool, along with those of all the other Eevee evolutions; I haven’t mentioned it in any of their entries because Normal attacks are generally less than stellar choices, but Glaceon is so desperate for weapons that it might be worth a shot.  Frost Breath, a weak Ice attack that always scores critical hits, is amusing against anything that favours Calm Mind or Amnesia but substantially weaker than Ice Beam otherwise.  Her abilities aren’t much help either; both improve her staying power in Hail, but weather strategies can be tricky to pull off at the best of times, Hail is easily the hardest to build a team around, and as we’ve already seen Glaceon has problems trying to act as a tank anyway.  Snow Cloak grants a helpful but unreliable 20% evasion chance (potentially good for use with Double Team, but Double Team is often frowned upon for its emphasis on luck); you’re probably better off with Ice Body, which lets Glaceon slowly regenerate in Hail, but that does invite rather unfortunate comparisons to Walrein, who does the same thing about a million times better.

 Cottondragon's (http://cottondragon.deviantart.com/) Glaceon against a sparkling night sky.

The really sad thing is that Glaceon isn’t even the only member of her family with powerful Ice attacks, because the rule that Water-types can use Ice moves seems to override the rule that Eevee’s evolutions aren’t allowed diverse offensive movepools.  Vaporeon’s Ice Beam is a lot weaker than Glaceon’s, naturally, but it’s also not the only thing she’s good at.   That, for me, sums up Glaceon’s problems; she simply doesn’t do anything special.  The designers seem to have decided that they needed a seventh evolved form for Eevee, but neglected to develop any sort of conceptual basis for what they were creating.  The end result is “Eevee, only blue and chilly,” which is a real pity because Ice is a fun type to work with and think about, and there’s nothing wrong with the idea of an Ice-type Eevee… it’s just not enough on its own.  Glaceon is just another of those Pokémon who needed a little more thought, never got it… and probably never will.

Questions, questions, questions…

Okay, so, when I left home this morning I had five unanswered questions waiting for me.  Now I have nine.

What do I think of Abomasnow, and how does Snow Warning work?  I think Abomasnow’s a great Pokémon; cool design, unique and interesting powers.  As for Snow Warning… well, it’s anyone’s guess.  I tend to stay away from trying to explain individual moves and abilities, because that way lies madness.

What do I think of Dusclops, and how he steps on Dusknoir’s nonexistent toes?  Again, great Pokémon.  Spooky, mysterious, evocative design, flavourful abilities, pretty much everything I could want from a Ghost-type.  I think the trouble with Dusknoir is that Dusclops never actually needed an evolution in the first place, and there just wasn’t any room to make Dusknoir all that much better.  Once the Eviolite came along…

What do I think of Magneton and do I think Klinklang is just a remake of Magneton?  Magneton, again, I like; they’re alien and inscrutable, with all kinds of weird powers resulting from their magnetism that make them dangerous and difficult to understand.  I’m not sure what Game Freak were smoking when they went with the whole flying saucer thing, but Magnezone is far from the worst design I’ve seen.  On Klinklang: http://pokemaniacal.tumblr.com/post/17760687580/klink-klang-and-klinklang

What do I think of Pikachu?  He’s adorable, and he has badass lightning powers; what more can you ask?  I really don’t understand the people who hate Pikachu; I think maybe that’s a reaction to the massive amount of hype that surrounds him, which, admittedly, I don’t think he deserves, though he’s still a very nicely done Pokémon.  I think he could stand to be a little faster and a little tougher (same goes for Raichu, come to think of it), because even with a Light Ball he’s still a very difficult Pokémon to use.

Am I going to review all the movies?  Good lord no; I’d have to watch Arceus and the Jewel of Life again.

Have I ever played Dragon Quest 5?  No.

Have I ever read the manga?  http://pokemaniacal.tumblr.com/post/32215051289/hi-new-reader-here-ive-just-finished-reading-your

What’s my favourite type and what do I think of adding extra types? http://pokemaniacal.tumblr.com/search/grass-types http://pokemaniacal.tumblr.com/post/27973745274/if-you-could-add-an-18th-type-to-the-type-listings-what

Why don’t I like humanoid Pokémon? http://pokemaniacal.tumblr.com/post/17760678969/gothita-gothorita-and-gothitelle http://pokemaniacal.tumblr.com/post/17760680127/scraggy-and-scrafty

Okay; I don’t know what exactly has happened in the last week, but I can’t handle it.  If you’ve only joined us in that time, I feel I should explain that this isn’t actually a question-and-answer blog.  It just looks like it at the moment if you see the front page.  Normally if I get an interesting question I like to set it aside for a day or two so I can think about it and give it a proper answer.  It’s getting to the point where, if I do that now, I’ll have four more questions to deal with when I come back.  I can only spend so many hours out of every day working on this blog and I kinda want to… y’know… keep actually writing stuff.  For this reason, I must regretfully start saying ‘no’ to these mini-analyses I’ve been doing.  I know I said I would try to do them all, and I’m sorry for backing out of that, but the thing about Pokémon is that there are over 600 of the damn things, and I have full-length entries on fewer than one third of them.  If I try to deal with everyone’s favourite and give little one-paragraph snippets on everything… well, you’re not going to be getting anything that’s had a lot of thought put into it; it’s going to be my opinion as much as anything else, and you can find opinions anywhere on the internet.

Other questions I will continue to answer as far as I am able, but if I have several, I’ll prioritise them according to how interesting they are, and I’m not going to try to answer more than one or two a day.  If there’s something you really want to know, take a look through the older entries.  You never know; I might have written a 2000-word article on it.  I’m going to see if I can get a search bar that doesn’t suck, so you can browse the older stuff properly.

Apologies to everyone who’s just gotten a half-assed answer to a question, but if I keep trying to answer everything, that’s all anyone’s going to get.

How do you feel about the whole Nurse Joy and Officer Jenny thing? You know… the fact that EVERY town and city in the world has one of each (or at least Nurse Joy if you’re only looking at the game)

I…

I don’t know.

*breaks down sobbing*

I DON’T KNOW!

*ahem*

I have, in fact, tried before to think of an explanation for this.  I inevitably come up with something that makes sense, but is completely out of place in the setting.  It’s not just that they have a close family resemblance, because a lot of them aren’t actually related by blood (the Cerulean Jenny, I remember, is the sister-in-law of the Viridian Jenny – they could also be related by blood in addition to being related by marriage, but it would have to be a fairly distant connection like second-cousin, otherwise they’d mention that relationship first).  I am unwilling to entertain the possibility that they are a legion of clones, because this is completely out-of-step with the way the world is generally portrayed.  I am forced to conclude that they refer to each other as ‘sister’ because they are members of two secretive monastic orders dedicated to medicine and law enforcement, respectively.  They ritualistically give up their own identities when they join and surrender their whole lives to the order, and must wear special makeup and clothing to suppress any distinguishing facial features.  They have held the contracts for staffing the nation’s Pokémon Centres and police stations since the Pokémon League began, maybe even longer, and their traditional methods produce the most elite nurses and policewomen in the world, whose entire lives are utterly dedicated to their work.

…yeah, this is one aspect of the Pokémon world I’m pretty sure we’re not supposed to take seriously.

Hi there! I’ve been reading your stuff here for a while now, and it’s been quite interesting. If you don’t mind, the obsessive Pokemon fan in me has a question for you: What are your views on the Spiky-eared Pichu, from an in-universe standpoint? Are there any particularly interesting implications to having this random Pichu who traveled through time at least once, and yet recognizes a shiny Pichu from the present? Why can it learn Pain Split while other Pichu cannot, and why can’t it evolve?

Ah, but you see, the thing about the Spiky-eared Pichu is that she is a character who is from the movie Arceus and the Jewel of Life.  And the thing about me and Arceus and the Jewel of Life, as you may find out if you’re reading through some of my older entries, is that we do not get along.  Specifically, I think it is a putrescent heap of hippo excrement that should ideally be placed in a hermetically sealed vault and shot into a black hole.  Unfortunately, if I were to give any thought at all to the in-universe implications of the Spiky-eared Pichu’s unusual status and powers, it would be tantamount to admitting 1) that Arceus and the Jewel of Life really happened, and 2) that some aspect of it might actually make sense.  

Thus, I must regretfully inform you that to answer your question would cause the very spark of my fundamental essence to extinguish itself and end my tormented existence on this harsh earth.

I mean… you say Espeon is your favorite. What does that mean?

I said Espeon was my favourite of Eevee’s evolutions.  My favourite Pokémon is Vileplume.

What I mean, though, is that I just like Espeon the best.  I have no coherent or defensible reason for liking Espeon the best, and it really comes down to my personal taste.  I try to keep that out of my analyses as much as I can – I’ll often think that a Pokemon is objectively well-designed even though I don’t really like it, because I can understand why it would appeal to other people with different tastes (Swampert, for instance); other times I’ll decide that a Pokémon is just badly thought-out and boring even though I myself have a certain affection for it (a lot of Grass Pokémon, like Lilligant, provoke this response, as well as Glaceon, whom I’ll be covering tomorrow).

Does that clear things up?

If we tell you our pokemon party, would you give a brief three sentence explanation of what to change, ‘cos I think I need some major changes in HG :/

Eh… frankly, there are better places you can go for that kind of advice.  I’m honestly not all that good at battling – I just read a lot of analyses and know all the tricks and jargon.  Try the forums at a site like Serebii.net or Smogon University; they’ll set you straight.

That, and I’m already having trouble dealing with everyone asking me about their favourite Pokémon; if people started asking for advice on team composition I’d probably be buried.

Hello from a fan! I love your blog so much I’ve introduced it to many a fellow Pokemon fan. But I realized that your “post categories” page, as far as I can tell, hasn’t been updated for your most recent series, including the Eevee-lutions and these awesome mini-Pokevaluations (hehe). Would you consider updating it, if you think it’s worthwhile and not too arduous a task? And… I guess while I’m at it, I really love Shroomish and am interested in what you think of it and Breloom! – AC

Yeah, I’m sort of used to the idea that I don’t need to change that page very often, because anything I’m currently working on is normally on the front page anyway.  It’s only in the last couple of weeks that people have started sending me two or three questions a day and swamping everything I write.  If this keeps up, I may need to rethink how the whole damn blog is organised.

Shroomish and Breloom?  Well, Shroomish I don’t find particularly interesting, although he does work with the decomposition aspect of mushrooms that Paras doesn’t look at, so he’s filling a niche that needed to be filled.  Breloom is crazy and awesome.  I don’t know how Game Freak managed to get from a little mushroom creature to a kickboxing dinosaur (or whatever he is… I suspect he may actually be intended to resemble a kangaroo, which would make sense) but I think it’s a wonderfully creative design.  They haven’t just taken an animal and converted it into a Pokémon, they’ve come up with something totally new and weird.  It doesn’t hurt, either, that Poison Heal is one of the best abilities gifted to any Pokémon ever, or that Spore (which, unlike Parasect, Breloom can use effectively because, again unlike Parasect, he can actually fight) makes for a brilliant combo with Focus Punch.