I like Mawile’s design a lot but it also equally confuses me… I’m assuming the feminine side with the yellow… fur? Is that where her head is… or is the brain in the plant-trap looking thing? And why Steel Type when it looks plant-like? Anyway, my point is to ask what do you think about her history/biology? (is it biology when its a Steel Type?)

I actually really like Mawile as well.  She’s one of the Pokémon I lump with Farfetch’d, Dunsparce and the like, where they’ve taken a really clever design, made it awful at everything, and then forgotten about it.  Poor Mawile…

Anyway.  I am led to understand that Mawile is probably based on an obscure Japanese monster – a woman with a second mouth growing out of the back of her head.  Game Freak seem to have adapted the idea by combining it with the concept of an animal which uses markings or unusual appendages to appear larger or more threatening than it really is (unlike, say, Girafarig, Mawile doesn’t actually have two mouths; according to the Pokédex the extra ‘jaws’ are really horns).  It’s a very fun, creative design, and I think it’s a shame Mawile had to… y’know… suck so much.  In answer to your question, then, just ignore the big jaws – that’s what she wants you to focus on.

As for why they decided to make her a Steel-type… you know, I honestly have no idea.  Her origins seem to fit with her being a Dark-type, and she’s portrayed consistently as a deceiver.  The Pokédex very insistently describes her jaws/horns as being made of steel, but that seems like it was a later choice to justify the typing, not the reason for it.  Quite aside from that, she has few typical Steel-type powers.  I guess you could interpret it as Mawile deliberately cultivating the appearance of one type when she actually belongs to another, thus continuing the theme of deception and making it more difficult for her enemies to attack her.

( my grammar might suck sorry ) what do you think of qwilfish? i know this is rota odd but do you think he is at all horrible i think he is one of the most boring pokemon ever i ask this because….well just because

What do I think of who?

Heh.  Sorry, couldn’t resist.

Qwilfish is, quite honestly, one of the few Pokémon I have ever just forgotten about completely.  Jim and I were looking through my Pokédex on Diamond a couple of years back and we found this empty spot and just stared at for about ten minutes before admitting we had no idea what the hell was supposed to go there.  I don’t know that this is entirely Qwilfish’s fault.  I think it’s largely because Game Freak have a tendency to hide him.  He doesn’t evolve, he’s too strong to be available early, and too weak to be useful later on, so he kinda winds up being one of those random Easter Egg Pokémon that most people only go looking for because they notice an empty space in the Pokédex and can’t figure out why.

I mean, I know he’s, like, supposedly a really good (if somewhat bizarre) Spiker/Toxic Spiker on a rain team or whatever, but is there really anyone, anyone in the world, who has an empty spot on their team and their very first thought is “Qwilfish would be awesome here”?

The sad thing is that he’s actually based on a comparatively interesting fish; it’s just that Game Freak have fallen into the typical Water-type trap of simply translating a real animal into Pokémon game mechanics and then going no further with it.  I don’t think he’s actually a Pokémon based on a porcupine fish at all; I think he’s legitimately just a porcupine fish.  So I suppose he wins badass points for being usable at all, right?

White 2 Playthrough Journal, episode 5: That’s Showbiz

Last time on Black and White 2, Jim and I had just managed a stunning defeat of Roxie, only to learn that we have apparently attracted the attention of some movers and shakers in the Unova film industry.  A talent scout approaches us as we leave the Virbank Gym, and explains that Pokéstar Studios needs kids like us.  Bemused, we follow him to the northern quarter of Virbank City, where the opulent palaces of Poké-Hollywood sprawl across vast tracts of land like great golden toads squatting on their lilypads, peering goggle-eyed at the hapless water insects swimming beneath them.  There, we are introduced to the eccentric golden-haired master of this place – Stu Deeoh.

Get it?  Stu Deeoh?  Because he owns a studio?  It’s a pun!  Oh, Game Freak, you kill me.

 It's difficult to show what the whole place looks like from a screenshot, so the anime's vision of Pokéstar Studios will have to do.

Stu conducts us to the great Pokéstar theatre to show us what he and his minions do in their palace of golden dreams.  Their most recent release, in fact, happens to be the debut appearance of Roxie’s father, the erstwhile captain of the Virbank-Castelia ferry service: an action-packed blockbuster entitled Brycen-Man.  The title character, to our immense shock, is played by none other than Brycen, the Icirrus City Gym Leader, returning to the silver screen after a long absence.  His luridly-costumed supervillain is opposed by Pop Roxie’s character, the similarly embroidered Riolu Man, in an epic battle set in an amusement park full of innocent bystanders.  Jim and I happily accept the complimentary tickets offered by Stu Deeoh, grab some popcorn, and settle in to watch the movie.

Afterwards, as we leave the theatre, Pop Roxie approaches us and nervously asks what we thought of his debut appearance.  I enthusiastically launch into a glowing encomium of Brycen-Man, proclaiming the film a work of comedic genius, with particularly high praise for Pop Roxie’s hilarious portrayal of the film’s antagonist, Riolu Man, a bumbling, stuttering goof whose ill-advised attempts to thwart the brilliant and unbelievably handsome title character provide riotous laughs from beginning to end.  Pop Roxie appears to be squirming and looking at his feet, no doubt from his modesty, so I tone it down a little and move into a discussion of the film’s clever inversion of the standard hero/villain paradigm that has us cheering for the title character even as he gleefully cuts a swathe of destruction through the innocent patrons of the amusement park.

At this point, Jim murmurs in my ear that we were supposed to be rooting for Riolu Man.

I pause in mid-sentence, my mouth hanging open.  By the time I manage to close it, Pop Roxie has slunk away through the shadows, forlornly muttering something about not quitting his day job.

Well.  Whoops.

 Remember this dude?  So, you might or might not have picked this up from Black and White, but he was totally a famous actor before becoming a Gym Leader, and now he's had a mid-life crisis and gone back to his old (ludicrously highly-paid) job.

Stu Deeoh soon tracks us down to ask how we would feel about joining the crew for his next cinematic masterpiece.  Jim declares that he has better things to do and suggests we return to the Virbank Complex for some level grinding, but I am intrigued by Stu’s offer.  If Brycen-Man is anything to go by, there’s clearly room in Pokéstar Studios for some exciting new talent – and who better than I?  Anyone can see, just to look at me, that I was born to be in the movies – perhaps in a sci-fi epic featuring a great interstellar empire and a reclusive order of mystical knights.  With visions of my future career all but materialising in front of me, I follow Stu Dio to his studeeoh to begin work on our first great project: a remake of Brycen-Man.  Apparently the movie was just such an appalling flop at the box office that Brycen is demanding we burn the film, eradicate all evidence of it, shoot the director, and start from scratch.  I protest that remaking a work of cinematic genius like Brycen-Man would be nothing short of sacrilege, but change my tune soon enough when I see the rewritten script, in which I have been cast as the spunky young heroine, Riolu Girl.  I stride onto the soundstage, take possession of the rental Pokémon who has been cast as my partner, and begin filming opposite Brycen.  Within a few short days, we have repurposed all of the original props and sets for Brycen-Man into a new blockbuster that brings both renown and profits to Pokéstar in spades… and so begins my movie career.

Everything I touch turns to gold.  Every director I work with proclaims my acting flawless, my interpretation of their characters genius, my delivery of key lines nothing short of divine.  I star in such acclaimed masterpieces as the Timegate Traveller trilogy, Mystery Doors of the Magical Land, and Red Fog of Terror, performing immaculately choreographed Pokémon battles alongside actors like Brycen and the mesmerising Kanto psychic, Sabrina, as well as some of the most highly trained Pokémon in showbusiness and a crew of the finest performance capture actors and CG artists in the industry.  My renown grows, and soon I am surrounded by fans, day and night, attempting to curry my favour with extravagant gifts.  I develop a crippling Rare Candy habit, and eat mainly poffins imported from Sinnoh at tremendous cost.  I take up Tai Chi to keep myself in shape, but quickly decide that it is too much work and hire someone else to take up Tai Chi for me.  One day, in one of my more lucid moods, I track down Stu Deeoh and ask him when I can expect to get paid for my work.

“Oh, dah-ling, we do not pay you!  That is so, ‘ow do you say, last season!  You are workink for us for ze sheer joy of your aaaht, are you not?”

 Pokéstar's costume designers are very well looked-after, and kept fully supplied with all the food, conveniences, entertainment and LSD they could ask for.

In fact, it turns out I actually owe Pokéstar a tremendous sum of money for the expensive food, clothing and massage treatments I’ve been purchasing through the company account on a daily basis.  This sum is known exactly to only a few of Stu Deeoh’s most trusted financial advisors, but is rumoured to exceed the GDP of Botswana.  Naturally, I do the honourable thing and book a ticket on the first ferry to Castelia City, instructing my Growlithe, Barristan, to set the company records office on fire as we leave.

Pokéstar Studios is an… interesting addition to the game.  As my experiences prove, it is exceptionally silly, but I have come to feel that it actually serves a legitimate and quite interesting purpose.  In concept it is reminiscent of Pokémon Contests and Musicals, in that your goal is to leverage your Pokémon’s ‘star power,’ as it were, but in practice it is strikingly different, since its central mechanic is essentially that of a choreographed Pokémon battle.  You are given a rental Pokémon and asked to fight one or more Pokémon belonging to another actor – but your aim is not simply to win, but to win in a particular fashion that suits the needs of the script.  Since you have a copy of the script, this is not especially challenging for an experienced player, even if the stage directions are often a little cryptic.  For a new player, however… well, obviously I don’t have the perspective required to evaluate it on those terms, but I think these scripted battles are actually a fantastic way to introduce new players to a wide variety of obscure moves and their effects.  The option to use your own Pokémon in place of rental Pokémon to shoot a film also puts a neat ‘puzzle-solving’ twist on the traditional Pokémon battle – the script has certain needs, and you have to prepare a Pokémon capable of fulfilling them.  Actually, I think the whole thing might have been more effective if it didn’t give the option of using a rental Pokémon after the initial screening of Brycen-Man and forced players to evaluate the requirements of the script for themselves, starting from very basic Pokémon and moves that can be obtained in and around Virbank City – but perhaps that would be too overwhelming for an inexperienced player?  In any case, frivolous though it may be, seen in the right light Pokéstar Studios is a great little diversion that puts a fascinating new spin on the central mechanic of the Pokémon games.  It also takes the unprecedented step of having your Pokémon battle against things that aren’t Pokémon.  Since most of Pokéstar’s movies use ridiculous amounts of computer animation, during filming these props are always seen as square slabs of green metal with icons on the front, though you can see the machines and monsters they represent when you watch the completed films.  They act as Pokémon in all respects, but have whatever stats, moves, abilities and elemental properties are demanded by the script.  This strikes me as a fascinating little ‘proof of concept,’ showing that the games can very effectively stage battles between Pokémon and objects to serve the needs of a plot.  I anticipate seeing more of this – in a less theatrical context – in future games.

Next time, I’ll be making a break for the ferry terminal… just as soon as I can find Jim.

Do you think that the X and Y legendaries could be based off on Norse Mythology? Look at the deer lookalike, the eagle lookalike, for the two realms. The third realm the underworld is a snake. MAybe Z = serpentine?

I feel I should make a general statement that my answer to any question of this kind about X and Y is going to be along the lines of “eh, whatever.”

I guess Yveltal, with the initial vocalic Y, does kinda sound like it could be Germanic or Nordic, but Xerneas doesn’t – I mean, I don’t really know anything about that language family but I’m not sure they even have an X sound, let alone words with an initial X.  Honestly it feels like a Greek name to me.  Also I just don’t think Yveltal looks like an eagle.  Something in the shape of the head, and the feathery collar, just screams ‘vulture’ to me.

EDIT: Another reader adds the following:

“There aren’t two realms in Norse mythology what? There is an eagle on the world tree, but there were actually four deer and also a dragon and a raven. It’s likely not Norse-related just because there’s a deer and an eagle.”

I think the first person was referring to the old division of the universe into heaven, earth and the underworld, which is common across many cultures, although from what I recall of Norse mythology, they actually had *several* realms, including two heavens, at least two underworlds, and possibly more than one earth… although I’m very much a Greco-Roman fellow and it has been a long time since I read anything on the subject.

Also I’m sure I remember something about a squirrel that used to carry insults up and down the World Tree between the eagle and Nidhogg…

You know what comes next, right?

So!  We have a winning concept for our Water/Fire Pokémon: the one proposed by Chewiana Jones, which I shall repeat here:

“What if we had an enormous squid/oil lamp hybrid that lived deep in arctic oceans, getting most of its nutrients from volcanic vents and small deep-sea Pokemon prey and burning oil (for warmth) in small amounts inside its body, which could look somewhat steampunk furnace-ish structure with more organic parts like the eyes and mouth mixed in and a body made of translucent, durable membrane with golden light shining through, supported by a skeletal framework. However, when it starts to run low on oil, it flares up its flames and rises like a hot air balloon to closer to the surface. There, it hunts pokemon like Walrein and Dewgong by expelling oil like squid ink and then lighting it on fire, then eats them and uses the oil for more power.”

Next step: art!  I need people to draw this thing!  Let your imagination go wild!  I’ve just created a new e’mail address for the blog – pokemaniac.chris@gmail.com – which you can use to send me pictures.  Alternatively, you can just use an image hosting site or something.  Just make sure you give me the name you want me to use to credit you!

Once we have a few submissions, we can vote on those and pick the best one.  Don’t feel you have to stick to the letter of the original concept – just as long as you keep to the spirit of it.  If anyone wants to suggest adjustments to the concept in the comments or whatever, please do so.  There’s already been one problem suggested with this idea – that this creature surfaces to hunt when it runs low on oil, and then… uses more oil to hunt.  Who can think of a way to fix that?

Do you think there’s some sort of in-joke with Froakie in X and Y? What I’m getting at is, Froakie is a frog, and the new region seems to be mostly based around Paris, France. And there’s a certain delicacy in France that Froakie just happens to be related to. You see where I’m getting with this? |3 So yeah, do you think that was intentional? (It’d be especially hilarious if Froakie’s later evolutions just happened to be chef themed. XD)

Well, not really, no.

I mean, don’t get me wrong; it’s far from impossible.  I just think that the announcement of a new generation of Pokémon is invariably accompanied by an absurd amount of speculation based on remarkably little evidence, and I prefer to stay out of it.  I suppose it would certainly be amusing.  I think the French themselves find being called ‘frogs’ offensive (understandably enough) so they might have to be careful how they spin something like that.  Also we don’t want to be tempting kids to eat their starters because that’s just bad for business.

What other pokemon items do you think about? I mean to list EVERY item you can give to a pokemon and how it actually works might be signing your death wish, but are any that you have a good idea for, or some that you hate to think about? My favorite is how the silk scarf apparently makes normal attack stronger

Eh.  I think about Pokéballs because they’re so unmissably integral to how the setting works.  How Pokéballs function has massive implications for the way Pokémon interact with humans, so I can’t really avoid the damn things.  Other items, not so much.

I think a lot of those type-boosting items are probably viewed as either confidence boosters of some sort (the scarf, the Hard Stone, maybe the Charcoal), as directly increasing the potency of attacks in some way (the Poison Barb, possibly the Magnet) or as being actually magical – it’s a common belief, for instance, that the body parts of magical creatures are magical as well, and Dragon Pokémon are ridiculously magical, so one of their fangs could very well have some sort of talismanic properties; we’re probably supposed to imagine something similar regarding the Mystic Water pendant.

I suppose some of the others might have special properties because they’re made of materials unavailable in the real world, for instance, the glass in Choice Specs is made from the ground-up core of a Starmie and bends the light in such a way as to reveal the points of a Pokémon’s body most vulnerable to magical attacks, or a Choice Scarf is made from… I don’t know, like, an Alakazam’s moustache hair or something.

The sixteen Plates, which determine Arceus’ nature and powers, are probably important, but goodness knows how they work.  In… *ahem*… that movie… Arceus is able to use all of the Plates he possesses at once, changing his type at will in order to block incoming attacks.  I think the way we’re supposed to see it is that Arceus, in his natural state, belongs to all types, but is in a weakened and diminished form without the Plates, which contain a portion of his ‘essence’ and can be used as a source of power either by him or by any other Pokémon.

So, yeah.  The answer is that for most items I don’t have a clue; don’t even ask about evolution stones (and don’t say ‘radiation’ because that isn’t an answer; that’s just more questions).

What do you think of the new designs about X and Ys new starters? I know you’re still early in on BW2. I’ve heard some interesting from other about the starter’s evolutions. For example I heard that Chespin is based off of a mole and a knight. That’d make for an interesting type combo (I’m thinking Grass/Steel or Fighting).

It’s sort of too early to tell.  The designs look a little bit generic, but that’s how they tend to start off; I’d really need to hear how they evolve.

The whole chestnut thing they seem to have going with Chespin is amusing enough.  I’d like to know where you heard this about a mole and a knight?  If you look at Chespin’s various names in other languages, it seems like they’re working off a hedgehog, not a mole (reasonably enough, since we already have mole Pokémon but not hedgehog Pokémon) but a knight is certainly possible.

EDIT: I stand corrected: Shaymin.  Still, I think we can all agree that nobody cares about Land Shaymin.

Fennekin… well, my biggest worry with Fennekin is that she’s going to be Vulpix.  There’s plenty of room in the design for her not to be Vulpix if they choose to take it in another direction, but the fact that she uses what seems to be a Psychic attack in the trailer makes me… uneasy.

People are making all kinds of predictions about Froakie, and saying he’s obviously going to go into Water/Flying because of the white parts on his body that look like fluffy clouds, and while that could potentially be interesting, I think the white is just as likely to represent foam, so… *shrug*

The bottom line, for me, is that people all over the internet are going to be wildly guessing at what these three are going to turn into.  By sheer dumb luck, some of them are going to be right, but they don’t know, and neither do I, and I don’t much care to join in.

White 2 Playthrough Journal, episode 4: Sex, Drugs and Pokémon

Official Nintendo art of Roxie.  Something in this design makes me feel like she should be a Bug-type specialist.  Is that just me?  I suppose her signature Pokémon *is* Whirlipede...At last permitted to leave Aspertia City and Floccesy Town behind us, Jim and I head for Virbank City.  Outside Floccesy Town, Cheren accosts us briefly to explain the significance of dark grass, something we remember perfectly well from Black and White, thank you very much.  I decide to muck around in the area for a while to see if any new Pokémon will appear here that we haven’t seen elsewhere on the route, and I am rewarded with a Venipede.  I add the spiky little bastard to my party, naming him Tyrion, and hang around to train him up a little.  Jim, meanwhile, heads east into Virbank City, and fields a call from our Dear Mother.  One of the other contacts available on our XTranceivers, Mother possesses an encyclopaedic knowledge of the Unova region and can tell us anything we might need to know about any area we visit.  We prefer to avoid Mother because she is a controlling bitch queen, but she has decided to call us this time, since we simply must know about the Virbank Complex, an industrial sector in the south of the city which is, for no goodly reason, infested with wild Pokémon.  The words ‘infested with wild Pokémon’ pique Jim’s interest, and he veers south to check the place out.  On the way, he takes a moment to eavesdrop on a domestic disturbance between two of the locals.  The captain who runs the ferry service to Castelia City is no longer fulfilling his duties, because he… has decided he would rather be a movie star.  Yes.  Well.  Fair enough, I suppose, but it leaves us trapped in Virbank City.  Well, we have Pokémon; we should be able to hijack a ship easily enough.  Of course, there are other, far less important, people who are also trapped in Virbank City, and it is on their behalf that the captain’s loud, angry daughter is taking him to task.  His daughter’s name is Roxie, and he has apparently been inspired by her – after all, she’s always managed to balance her passion for rock music with her responsibilities as a Gym Leader, so-

Wait, what?

Okay, all right.  The punk chick is the Gym Leader.  We can work with this.

I catch up with Jim as he tails Roxie to a small, dingy building in the middle of Virbank City.  I open the door, revealing a dilapidated, poorly lit stairwell, and immediately stagger as I am hit by the stench of dried vomit.  The faint sound of music wafts up from the basement.  We have apparently followed Roxie to a seedy nightclub.  Jim points out the Unova League insignia in flickering pink neon over the entrance, and the sign by the door which reads ‘Virbank City Pokémon Gym.  Leader: Roxie.  Poison days, poison on the stage!’  Poison in the air too, I think to myself, peering at the unidentifiable stains on the concrete floor.  I shake my head firmly and hold up both of my palms in protest.  Jim looks at me accusingly and points down the stairs.  I hold my nose and continue shaking my head.  Jim rolls his eyes, grabs me by the collar and drags me off to the Virbank Complex for some training. 

 The Virbank complex.  Screenshot stolen from Serebii.net.

The Virbank Complex seems to be an oil refinery, filled with tanks, distillation towers, and smokestacks.  Naturally the game puts on its ‘educational’ hat at this point by introducing a scientist who wanders around the complex muttering explanations to himself about how all the different pieces of equipment work, and running away if anyone overhears him.  As profoundly strange as this man is, I have to applaud the effort.  I really do like it when Pokémon tries to do this sort of thing, just because I like entertainment to be educational on principle (if you’re clever, you can trick the kids into learning stuff without even realising it) but it’s not exactly subtle; it feels rather ‘pasted on.’  The Slateport Oceanic Museum in Ruby and Sapphire made a bit more sense, if only because oceanography is actually relevant to the plot of those games, and the Oreburgh coal mine in Diamond and Pearl was at least trying to integrate things into the game by using Pokémon workers.  Anyway, in blatant defiance of any pollution the place might be pumping out, the Virbank Complex is overgrown with tall grass and teeming with many different species of wild Pokémon – offering us a perfect opportunity to beat some Pokémon up for their sweet, precious XPs.  Most of our Pokémon evolve as we train here; first Sansa and Elisif become a pair of adorable Flaafy, then Jaime evolves into a feisty Dewott and Ulfric into a cunning Servine.  Finally, almost unthinkably, Jim’s Riolu, Dovahkiin, evolves at a shockingly low level into a noble Lucario.  We both decide to pick up Fire Pokémon while we’re here – Jim catches a Magby and names him Falk, while I find a Growlithe.  Ruminating on names, I briefly consider Tywin, but reflect that my party is fast turning into Team Lannister, and settle instead on Barristan (I receive immediate confirmation that I chose correctly when my Growlithe’s nature turns out to be Bold).  Suitably prepared for battle, we return to the filthy dive in which Roxie has chosen to make her Gym.

I stagger down the stairs holding my nose as Jim walks ahead trying to pretend he doesn’t know me.  We come to the basement and enter what appears to be a studio owned by Roxie’s band.  Roxie herself is up on the stage, eyes screwed shut, caressing her electric guitar, accompanied by a second guitarist and a drummer.  I am forced to take my hand away from my nose to plug my ears as Jim clambers onto the stage to challenge Roxie, who is totally oblivious to the world outside her guitar.  Jim looks down at me, shrugs, and goes to talk to her marginally more aware backup musicians.  While he tries to get their attention, I haul myself onto the stage and, unable to take any more, push aside Roxie’s long white hair and scream in her ear, as loud as I can manage,

 The Virbank Gym.  Screenshot stolen from Bulbapedia.

“YOUR MUSIC SUCKS!”

That gets her attention.

Tyrion, luckily, is quite as annoyed as I am.  With the classic Defence Curl/Rollout combo, he manages within a few turns to build up enough force to smash Roxie’s Koffing.  Now several turns into his Rollout, there’s no question of Roxie being able to do anything about him, and her poor Whirlipede is made to suffer the indignity of a one-shot knock-out from one of its own lesser cousins.  Roxie indignantly throws a Toxic Badge at me and tells me to get the hell out of her Gym, before healing her Pokémon for the next challenger.  Of course, with Dovahkiin now a Steel-type and therefore immune to all of Roxie’s most powerful Poison techniques, Jim’s challenge is quite as much a walkover as mine was, and we leave Roxie a broken wreck, sobbing over her guitar as her backup musicians give us dirty looks.

A man with brilliant yellow hair tails us as we leave, apparently anxious to speak to us.  He is somewhat taken aback when I collapse, gasping for breath, on the street the moment we leave the noxious Gym, but to his credit presses on, telling us about the exciting new opportunity he wants to offer us at Pokéstar Studios in the north of Virbank City…