I just read your Celebi writeup and i noted a certain resemblance to Lord English from Homestuck. (Lord English is a time traveling demon demon born at the end of the universe, who manipulates events to perpetuate his own existence. The main difference is that he is incredibly evil.) Was this intentional?

…huh.

You know, I didn’t specifically have Lord English in mind when I wrote that, but I suppose, now that you mention it, that there are some marked similarities in concept.  They are also both green.

Sorry for the intrusion, but what are your opinions about Cherubi and Cherrim? They’re two of my favourites(I even used them in White 2, since I got him in a trade), even though I know they’re rather useless.

(Sorry about taking so long to get around to this; have been very busy lately)

Cherubi and Cherrim are… meh.  You might recall my general distaste towards Sunflora for being a Grass Pokémon whose thing is that she likes sunlight – a characteristic shared by all Grass Pokémon – and this bugs me about Cherrim as well, but at least she can claim to have a unique mechanical and thematic quirk that shows her association with sunlight is stronger than it is for most other Grass-types.  The design is not particularly inspired, but the choice of a cherry is admittedly a nice touch, since the shift from cherry fruit to cherry blossom allows for a dramatic change which still makes intuitive sense and is easy to comprehend (especially for a Japanese audience).  I don’t think they really needed to be in the game, exactly, and it’s clear that they don’t have much of a battling niche outside of doubles, but… I guess I’m not that upset that they exist?  Uh.  So yeah.

Why do you ignore Lilligants access to Own Tempo and Petal Dance? It’s one of the only Pokemon that can use a move like that with no consequence!

Because it’s still a bad idea.

The confusion isn’t even really the worst part of moves like Petal Dance, because you can always just switch out.  The trouble is being locked into those moves, and unable to switch out, while they continue.  Dragon-types can get away with using Outrage because so few Pokémon resist Dragon attacks, and even then it’s kind of a gamble.  If you’re using Petal Dance, your opponent basically has a free switch to any of the seven elements that resist Grass attacks (and if Petal Dance keeps going for a third turn and gives the switch-in a chance to set up, you might really be in trouble).

I mean, it’s not useless, but it’s not really good enough that it becomes a better option than Chlorophyll.

I was looking at your review of the Sewaddle family and I noticed that you said you don’t get why Swadloon looks so grumpy, it’s actually a joke that Swadloon is a hikikomori, to evolve it has to be truly happy (I think Gamefreak put that in as an aesop) Leavanny’s Japanese name is even a pun on it!

What did I actually say about Swadloon?  I’m not sure I even remember.  I’ll look it up.

Oh yeah.  Yeah, that’s right.  I didn’t really get it, but I still liked it.  Hmm.  Well, I have no idea what a hikikomori is, but I’ll take your word for it that it makes sense.

h t t p : / / i . i m g u r . c o m / m b P D Z 9 4 . j p g Opinions?

Well, it’s a little simplistic, and there are a number of specific points I disagree with, but I suppose my ultimate opinion is really just “sure, why not?”  Might write up a more thorough reflection on this later.

P.S. A clickable link for other readers (Tumblr, for some inane reason, forbids the use of links in questions) http://i.imgur.com/mbPDZ94.jpg

Well, there’s official news of a new pokemon that’s just been revealed that’s stated to appear in the next movie. One that’s either a new form of Mewtwo, or an entirely different pokemon that’s related to mewtwo in some way. Some even say it might be Mewtwo fused with either Mew or Genesect. What are your individual thoughts if its either one of these things?

Well, I don’t really like speculating on this stuff, because I just don’t see the point of that.  Any of those ideas could be used well or badly. None of them are ‘safe,’ and none of them really set off alarm bells in my head.  I like that they appear to be doing something new with an old Pokémon, especially one as iconic as Mewtwo, and the possibility that, after all these years, there really is going to be a Mewthree is, if nothing else, amusing.  If they plan to work with the idea of Mewtwo going back to the technology that created him and using it for his own ends, that could be interesting.  Not sure how else I’d do it.

How does poliwhirl/wrath eat? The pokedex makes such a song and dance about his intestines, but he lost his mouth when he evolved.

Well, personally I assume they do have mouths (at the centre of the spiral, since that’s where their Water Guns originate in the anime) but that they’ve become smaller and less obvious, so we can’t actually see them in the art and sprites.  Alternatively, they may adapt to absorb nutrients directly from the water around them, although this seems unlikely to me, since Poliwhirl is supposed to be more suited to life on land than Poliwag.

Have you seen the new trailer for the Genesect movie? It seems that they’re so shameless about how much Genesect copies Mewtwo that they actually decided to have Mewtwo appear in the movie. Now not even the new generation of fans will be fooled by such a rehash. XD How hilarious do you find this?

Honestly, I actually like that this is what they’re doing.  If you’ve got two very similar designs, then (in my opinion, anyway) the absolute worst thing you can do is avoid the issue, because then you’re just being lazy, everyone knows it, and you wind up with this irritating redundancy.  I think throwing the two into conflict, in order to accentuate their similarities, make a point of it, and also throw any differences into relief, is actually one of the best ways I can imagine of handling Genesect.