I, uh… I’m afraid part 2/2 seems to have become lost in the celestial aether.
Tag: QandA
Why is Corsola in the Water1/Water3 egg group, and not Mineral? Water1 is composed of amphibians and aquatic mammals, and water 3 is shellfish and cephalopods. What in the distortion world IS coral?
Well, as I understand it, coral is a sort of communal organism not altogether unlike a jellyfish, but sedentary and hard-bodied, so Water 3 makes a lot of sense. Water 1, to be honest, is composed of all kinds of insane nonsense and I’m not sure there’s any point looking for a consistent rationale there. To me it seems like the primary idea of that group is ‘Water-types that are also comfortable on land,’ and Corsola does fit that, although it does put us in strange places when we start making comparisons to real-world evolutionary biology. If anything I’m actually a lot more puzzled about Clamperl and Horsea being in that group.
I have a question relating to ancient Greece. Do you know when the city of Athens was first called “Athens” in recorded history? And was the name always recognized as being from the goddess Athena, or did her invention come later? It will help me greatly in inspiration for my stories.
Kind of a tricky question. If memory serves, Homer refers to the city of Athens by name in the Catalogue of Ships, and you can argue ad nauseam about the actual age of Homer in general or that passage in particular, but it’s certainly one of the oldest things in Greek literature. In any case I’d be happy to accept that the names of both the city and the goddess go back to the beginning of the ‘historical’ period.
Before that… well, there was almost certainly a Mycenaean citadel on the Acropolis in the Late Bronze Age, and people have drawn a connection here with the various jumbled stories about Erechtheus, the mythical king of Athens, living in Athena’s temple (the Mycenaeans didn’t have temples, as far as we can tell; religious and political authority were probably united under one roof). We don’t know what the Mycenaean city was called, though. I would bet good money it was something like the Classical “Athenai” because place names tend to be conservative, but we have no Linear B from Athens, so it’s not really possible to be airtight on that. One of the Knossos tablets does mention something called a-ta-na po-ti-ni-ja, and po-ti-ni-ja is a title commonly given to goddesses (the later Greek equivalent is potnia, which is one of the things Homer calls Athena), so possibly the reference is to a goddess called “Mistress Atana,” and just conceivably it might indicate that Athena is ultimately an aspect of the Minoan “great goddess” (and here much is made of the fact that snakes are sacred to Athena). The trouble is, these texts don’t actually tell us anything about the gods they mention; they’re just lists of the resources allocated to festivals and sacrifices and such, for accounting purposes. So we know that Athena probably exists and is worshipped in the Bronze Age in one form or another, but we don’t know whether she was anything like the Classical goddess, and we have no idea what, if any, connection she has to the city of Athens.
So yeah.
It just occurred to me that if Geodude was just revealed as a preview of the next generation of pokemon, we’d be laughing at it’s goofy name, but instead we had it since gen 1 and we didn’t even think about it back then. Huh.
…would we? I’m… not sure I agree with that at all. But sure, whatever.
I read over a bit of your “If I was in charge”, and have you ever considered joining up with some spriters and coders to make it a reality? I mean, there are projects dedicated to creating new Pokemon fan games, and hacks besides, and couldn’t the people who make those be just as willing to make something spectacular?
Eh… not that it isn’t a nice thought, but… too much work. Far too much work. I can barely keep up with my regular writing at the moment.
Wo haben Sie Deutsch gelernt? Sind Sie je in Deutschland? Was ist Ihre Lieblingsdeutschpokemonname?
Eh… ich spreche nicht so gut, aber ich muss für mein Promotionsstudium manchmal Deutsch lesen (mit einem Wörterbuch), weil viele wichtige Archäologen in Deutsch schreiben und veröffentlichen. Ich bin noch nie nach Deutschland gegangen, aber ich würde gerne!
Soweit, mein Lieblingsdeutschpokemonname ist Schluppuck! Es ist so wunderbar onomatopoetisch!
They gotta bring Berserk genes back. (and the softboiled tm/tutor)
Do they, though? Do they really?
What is the likelihood that we’ll ever get a Grey version? Also, what if it took place in the past, perhaps during the Reshiram/Zekrom split or the Kalos/Unova war?
Well, the likelihood, I would estimate, is “close to zero.” They’re done with that generation; they’ve moved on; they’re doing other things now. Unless the remake train keeps steaming on to the point that we actually get remakes of Black and White, I doubt it’ll ever happen. Setting it in the mythical past would be cool, but the trouble is that it does sort of lock certain things in – like, we know that Reshiram and Zekrom destroyed Unovan civilisation the last time they fought. It happened; the player can’t win and the story can’t have a happy ending. Unless of course they’re willing to pull some kind of alternate universe situation, of the sort implied by Delta Episode, where this hypothetical Grey version is actually a prequel to a completely different version of the Black and White universe that we’ve never seen. That would be kinda weird.
Was Kalos at war with Unova? I always got the impression it was a civil war; I don’t think Unova is ever mentioned in connection with that conflict.
So, now that we have had mega evolution for a while, do you think you could make some mega-evolution designs for some of the pokemon on your ‘worst pokemon’ list?
Eh. To be honest, designing mega evolutions for things is not something that I find all that interesting. And I actually did sketch out concepts for evolutions for most of those Pokémon, so, like… it would kind of serve exactly the same purpose as what I did with them in the first place.
Sentret was the original sentry rodent pokemon. That unholy terror patrat stole the concept. They already got the normal rodent pokemon template perfect with Furret’s adorableness, and the normal rodent pokemon get uglier and uglier in each subsequent generation.
Meh. I prefer Bidoof.
