…I’m not sure what you’re asking. Other than the fact that Dodrio is apparently slower than Doduo (who is described in Crystal, Emerald and Fire Red as running at 60 miles per hour) it all seems perfectly reasonable.
Author: pokemaniacchris
If i could return to the subject of the new Eeveelution for a second, Do you think it could be an Eevee specificly adapted to living with, and appealing to, upper class humans? Like the pokemon show judges in Pearl/Diamond/Platinum?
*shrug* Sure; makes as much sense as anything else.
Okay, who’s good at doing stat spreads?
As you may know, we’re all making a new Pokémon here – a Water/Fire squid Pokémon, with the following description from Chewiana Jones:
“What if we had an enormous squid/oil lamp hybrid that lived deep in arctic oceans, getting most of its nutrients from volcanic vents and small deep-sea Pokemon prey and burning oil (for warmth) in small amounts inside its body, which could look somewhat steampunk furnace-ish structure with more organic parts like the eyes and mouth mixed in and a body made of translucent, durable membrane with golden light shining through, supported by a skeletal framework. However, when it starts to run low on oil, it flares up its flames and rises like a hot air balloon to closer to the surface. There, it hunts pokemon like Walrein and Dewgong by expelling oil like squid ink and then lighting it on fire, then eats them and uses the oil for more power.”
(It has been pointed out that it doesn’t make much sense for this thing to come up and hunt when it’s low on oil and then spray oil everywhere in order to hunt. A couple of people have suggested emendations but none of them have me convinced yet. I’m beginning to think that it may be best to go with the simplest possible explanation – it acquires much more oil than it uses when it hunts.)

Design by Adam.
The poll I set up to determine this thing’s battle role has been somewhat inconclusive, with equal votes going to ‘sweeper’ and ‘revenge killer.’ Rather than go through another poll, I’m just going to rule that this thing is biased towards aggressive play, with relatively limited defensive and support skills, and move on. Next thing to be done is stats, movepool, abilities, and so on – if you want to take a shot at it, send some form of document to me at pokemaniac.chris@gmail.com containing the following:
- Stats – I’m going to impose a maximum base stat total of 540; this is the highest number at which you can find multiple non-legendary Pokémon (excluding Dragonite, Tyranitar, etc). Remember, though, there are plenty of effective Pokémon well down into the 400’s, and a couple of surprisingly silly ones even at 600 and above.
- Abilities – up to three; if it has two or more, one should be designated a Dream World ability.
- Level-up moves – including, if desired, 0-level moves learnt using a Heart Scale.
- The 5th-generation TMs and HMs it can use – preferably ordered by number. Note: all Pokémon that can use TMs can learn Toxic, Hidden Power, Protect (except Regigigas), Frustration, Return, Double Team, Facade, Rest, Round, Swagger and Substitute, and all Pokémon with gender can learn Attract (with a couple of exceptions which are probably oversights).
- The B2/W2 tutored moves it can learn – preferably ordered alphabetically. Note: all Pokémon that can use move tutors can learn Sleep Talk and Snore.
- Egg moves – I’m making the executive decision that this thing belongs in the Water 3 egg group, with Tentacruel, Omastar and Cloyster, among others. I know Octillery is in Water 2, but I suspect this is only because it evolves from Remoraid; all the other Water 2 Pokémon are fish. Before giving this Pokémon an egg move, please check that something else in Water 3 can actually learn it! If chain breeding is required, include a note explaining the required chain. If you want to give this thing a secondary egg group, please give your reasoning.
I’m going to rule that people have one week from now to make submissions – after that, I post them all here and open a poll to choose one.
Any questions?
Your take on Normalize?
As for how it works, I have absolutely no clue, but I do have an old entry on Delcatty you might enjoy reading.
I’ve been introducing my friend to Pokemon and she has had many questions about the “backstory” of the world (as she put it) so I directed her here and she’s loved your stuff! However, she wanted to know what you thought about Shiny Pokemon in terms of how they work in the game’s universe. From what I’ve seen, the games and show only briefly mention the different colors some Pokemon have or can sometimes flat out ignore it. Do you think it’s just a uniform mutation? How does Red Gyrados fit in?
Hrmm.
My knowledge of the anime is actually somewhat limited; the only shiny Pokémon I know of other than the famous red Gyarados is Ash’s Noctowl, who is also notable for his small size and exceptional intelligence. Except in Gold, Silver and Crystal, shiny Pokémon don’t have unusual stats, though; they’re just like any other Pokémon except for their colours. I suppose I would say that the odd pigmentation is just the result of some rare recessive gene, like albinism, or Elizabeth Taylor’s famous violet eyes. In some Pokémon, this unusual trait might guarantee them important leadership positions, in other species, it might make them pariahs, in still others it might be ignored completely.
I noticed what you thought of Krabby and Sandshrew, finding them kind of boring, so I wanted to ask about this topic… Take Dewgong for example, its an incredibly simple design but I really love it because its sleek and beautiful. I find myself liking Pokemon like that (Vulpix, Rapidash, Venemoth, Gengar…). More recent Pokemon seem to have overly bright colors and contrasts and cluttered patterns that aren’t terrible, just not as appealing to me. What do you take from that in your opinion?
I have mixed feelings about this. I actually prefer the more complex designs that tend to prevail in the later generations, but there’s definitely something to be said for simplicity. It’s not just the art that bugs me about Krabby and Sandshrew, though – pretty much everything noteworthy about Krabby and Kingler’s abilities and behaviour is true of fiddler crabs as well. Sandshrew and Sandslash are at least changed a little, because the animals they’re based on, pangolins, aren’t desert creatures, but they have a very generic set of “desert creature” traits. Honestly I think that in some ways real pangolins are more interesting. You can’t really make a complaint like that about Vulpix or Gengar. Rapidash, Venomoth and Dewgong are sort of borderline cases (although, as a question of personal taste, I do have a soft spot for Venomoth and Dewgong).
Short answer: the art is only part of the question for me.
Sylveon is the English name for the new Eevee Evolution who is pink with butterfly ribbons, feminine features and a name similar to the name Sylvia… Do you think its possible that Sylveon might be a Normal-Type female only evolution and that there will also be a Normal-Tyle male only eevee evolution seeing as we’re talking about Pokemon X and Y? *cough* chromosomes *cough*
Well, sylphs are air spirits, so it actually makes me lean in the direction of Flying…
White 2 Playthrough Journal, episode 10: City of Lights

I hurry into Nimbasa City, and immediately run into Jim, who is standing outside the central subway station, deep in conversation with two official-looking men in ridiculous coats. He seems surprised to see me, and remarks that he thought it would take me at least a day to run Join Avenue into the ground. I shrug and suggest that maybe I’m just that good. Jim rolls his eyes and introduces me to his friends the Subway Bosses, Ingo and Emmet (no, neither of us knows which is which, and we don’t care). They run Nimbasa City’s subway system, which as public transport goes is pretty frightful… not because it’s expensive – it isn’t – or because the trains don’t run on time – they do – or because the subway network isn’t extensive enough – it is – but because you can only use the subway if you are a Pokémon trainer, and must win seven consecutive battles before reaching your destination. If you fail, you are not permitted to get off the train at the other end, and in fact you are unceremoniously dumped back where you started. Since every battle has a winner and a loser, not many people make it to seven consecutive wins and get where they’re going on the first try, but they keep it up anyway, bless them. Rush hour is an absolute nightmare, and heaven help you if you have to take more than one train. For less skilled trainers, getting from the outer suburbs to the central city is a four-day commute. Jim is astonished. In our city of Auckland, the same trip would take three weeks. Ingo and Emmet have apparently agreed to share their secrets if he can defeat them in a double battle, and my arrival is thus rather fortuitous. Jaime and Ulfric are able to deal quickly with the subway twins’ Boldore and Gurdurr, apparently the only Pokémon they deign to use in a casual match. Unfortunately, they prove unwilling to make good on their promise, and instead vanish, cackling, into the subway tunnels.
Nimbasa City, like Castelia, is much as we remember it. The great and small stadia are open for business as usual, the Pokémon Musical theatre still stands, despite the fact that no one ever actually goes there by choice, and the Battle Institute remains open, though it seems to have developed a snobbish streak and is no longer admitting anyone who cannot boast of a Pokémon League victory. We, however, are drawn only by the amusement park – the site of the Nimbasa City Gym. Jim and I make a beeline for the great rollercoaster, only to find that the Leader, Elesa, being even more ADHD than all the other Unova Leaders, was not satisfied with mere renovations and has instead constructed a whole new building in which to hold court. Apparently she’s at the rollercoaster right now, though, doing… something. Presumably something important. One hopes. We obediently fight our way through the rollercoaster, which has maintained a complement of Pokémon trainers despite no longer being a Gym, only to find – surprise! – Elesa has finished whatever she was doing and gone home. With a resigned sigh, we turn around and head for the new Nimbasa Gym, which is also in the theme park. We enter, and…

Okay, well, we knew Elesa was a model, but really? The Gym is her own personal catwalk? Good lord; the place is a monument to her own ludicrous self-absorption. Well, there’s only one thing to be done: take her down a peg or three. Clyde the guide, as usual, appears at the entrance to advise us of the weaknesses of the Gym’s specialty type, in this case, Ground, but he manages this time to add a very important corollary which he forgot on Black and White: don’t try it on Emolga. In fairness, on Black and White most of the trainers in the Gym used Emolga, so if you hadn’t clued up by the time you reached Elesa you were really asking for it, but it’s still a bit of a rotten trick to play on anyone new to the game. Anyway, that’s fixed; whoo. Jim and I make our way up Elesa’s catwalk, knocking her three underlings aside as we go. I note, with amused approval, their names: Nikola, Fleming, and Ampère, doubtless named for Nikola Tesla, John Fleming, and André-Marie Ampère, pioneers in the study and manipulation of electricity. Elesa herself is perched at the far end of the catwalk. She welcomes us warmly, and-
“What, no puzzles?”
Elesa looks at Jim in confusion. He challenges her to explain what kind of half-assed Gym doesn’t have puzzles, or at least some sort of maze. Elesa mutters something about the price of the new construction and all the stage lights. Jim glares at her imperiously and demands a puzzle. Elesa, quite flustered now, thinks to herself for a moment and tries a riddle.
“I am, in truth, a yellow fork, from tables in the sky by inadvertent fingers dropped, the awful cutlery of-”
“Is it a bolt of lightning?” Elesa hangs her head.
“…take the damn badge and get out.”
I step up as Jim heads back along the catwalk. “Can I have a rid-”
“No.”
I call out my secret weapon, Daenerys the Trapinch, whose Rock Slide quickly does in Elesa’s Emolga. Her Zebstrika proves a more difficult customer, but is seriously debilitated by Daenerys’s Bulldoze and Barristan’s Intimidate, leaving it easy prey for the bold Growlithe. Finally, her Flaaffy manages valiantly to overcome Barristan, but has too little strength left at the end to go toe-to-toe with Tyrion, and barely manages to paralyse him with Thunder Wave before succumbing to his attacks. Elesa decides to make the best of her situation and hands me my Bolt Badge with all the ceremony she can muster, before leading me in triumph down the catwalk as fans scream with delight.
Good grief; I hope no one from Pokéstar Studios is watching.

Elesa’s Gym is lovely and flashy, and she certainly knows how to put on a spectacle, but when it gets right down to it, all you’re doing is walking through the Gym in a straight line, defeating the trainers in your way. I like the way the fifth generation games have tried to personalise their Gyms a bit more, making them appropriate to the personalities of their Leaders – Lenora’s library quiz in Black and White, for instance, or even the purely decorative addition of Burgh’s artist’s loft in the new Castelia Gym – and in that respect it is nice that, since Elesa is supposed to be a famous model, she gets a catwalk (I suppose Roxie’s Gym is similar, in that way). Part of the fun of a Gym challenge, though, is that (well, in most cases) you actually have to navigate some sort of obstacle other than the purely combative ones provided by the trainers, obstacles which have tended to become more elaborate and interesting as the series has progressed. I would almost suggest that Elesa’s Gym should have been integrated with the Pokémon Musical system, if not for the fact that the Pokémon Musical is such an irritating and gimmicky little sideshow in its own right. In short, the new Nimbasa Gym is all flash and no substance – unsurprisingly, I suppose, for an Electric-type Gym.
Next time, we’ll be exploring the environs of Nimbasa City… and checking up on dear, sweet Hugh…
Okay, i know what you’re like, so i know your answer to begin with. But i was hoping you could explain WHY everyone is so negative to the idea of “light” type. I mean, it’s not asif it’s too similar to a type already and everyone saying it might ‘break’ the type chat more seem to be basing that on no logic whatsoever. The only other time they added more types (dark and steel) as to fix the thpe chart (abit)
Do you mean ‘negative’ or ‘skeptical’? Those are two very different things, and there are people going both ways.
I’m not sure I can answer why people might be negative about it, because personally I’m not. I might have said before that, if I were going to add a new type, I’d go with Light or Holy, although I don’t think the game needs it. If they are going to add a new type, that’s fine by me. I can only pray that it does a better job of creating balance than Steel did.
I’m skeptical that this is what they’re doing because I simply don’t think we have sufficient evidence to conclude something like that. I’ve seen people’s arguments that Ninfia and Xerneas are Light-types, and they do not convince me. I still think Ninfia is a Bug-type, and I have no clue what Xerneas is, but really, that means little. How many people picked Palkia as a Water-type before Diamond and Pearl were released? How many people were convinced Reshiram was going to be a Light-type?
Of course, I don’t think we have sufficient evidence to conclude that they’re not adding Light as an element either. Since we’re all going to find out sooner or later, I’m not sure what all the fuss is about. I am the very soul of apathy on this matter.
What’s your view on human-shape pokemon? I’ve always found the Mr. Mimes and Sawks of this world kind of odd, because they awkwardly are made to look human-but-not-quite. There’s always been a lot of lambasting of Jynx and Mime from the beginning, but Gamefreak seem happy to churn out a new human every generation (see Hitmons, Ralts line and Gothitelle). Why would it be beneficial for a pokemon to look like a person? And if they’re psychically/mentally superior why haven’t they taken over?
Well, Jynx gets flak because someone pointed out that she resembles an actor in blackface, and could therefore be interpreted as a racist caricature (personally I don’t think this is what they intended at all, but they could have been a little more careful with what they were doing), not necessarily because of the humanoid thing. I think there is a degree of ‘uncanny valley’ in it, but then, people love Gardevoir (personally I think Gardevoir looks markedly less human than Jynx or Gothitelle, but whatever). Personally, I get annoyed when they build Pokémon around elements of contemporary culture, like Gothitelle and Scrafty, because I think the ones that work with traditional culture and mythology are just more interesting and can also work more effectively with the idea of the massive cultural debt humans have to Pokémon in this universe, but I suppose maybe that’s just my personal taste.
I actually think “why would it be beneficial for a Pokemon to look like a person?” is a backwards way of looking at it, because the Pokémon may well have come first. And we have that in the real world, actually; humans are just one of four surviving genera of great ape (the others being chimpanzees, gorillas and orangutans), all of which bear marked physical similarities to us. In this case, it’s because we share a common ancestor with them – is this true in the Pokémon world too? Are humans related to Pokémon of the humanshape group? Possibly; who knows? And as for why they haven’t taken over – well, this applies equally to all Pokémon, and it links in with one of the most important questions of the setting: there are clearly a lot of things Pokémon do better than humans, so what is there that humans do better than Pokémon? Personally I think the answer is related to creativity and leadership, but that’s a tricky one indeed. You also have to question what is meant by “taking over” in this context – humans have a civilisation characterised by agriculture, industrialisation, art, education, and so on… but I have to wonder whether Pokémon would necessarily view any of these things as benchmarks of success. If they simply didn’t want any of that, would that be enough to ‘prevent’ them from ‘taking over’?
